USA: Hinrichtung stoppen!

(auf Englisch)

David Roberts was charged with the capital murder of "AJ", the girlfriend of the man ("WS") in whose house Roberts was staying. On 22 April 1992, AJ was shot and killed in the house, which was then set on fire. David Roberts, then 26, became a prime suspect and was subjected to 25 hours of questioning without a lawyer present. He made a series of inconsistent statements including two implicating himself in murder and arson. 

In November 1992, the prosecutor offered a deal whereby David Roberts would plead guilty in return for a sentence of life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. However, this was not relayed to David Roberts by his lawyer until the first day of trial, 14 December 1992, when the lawyer asked his client to enter a guilty plea. David Roberts refused to, and the trial began. The defence lawyer was ill-prepared, having hired no experts, including to assess his client’s psychological health and history. The same lawyer was later suspended by the Alabama Bar Association for misconduct in other cases, eventually losing his license to practice law. International law requires that anyone facing the death penalty be provided "adequate legal assistance at all stages of proceedings".

A day before the murder, WS had been on trial on charges of burning down his own furniture store for insurance. David Roberts’ father was to be a witness against him, and AJ was too. At David Roberts’ trial, the prosecutor acknowledged that WS may have been involved in the crime of 22 April 1992 but told the jury that this was not an issue for them. On appeal, this comment was deemed to have been a fair reply to the defence closing argument that WS had "some kind of power" over David Roberts, and that no one knew exactly what had happened at the murder scene. The jury convicted David Roberts on 16 December 1992 after a two-day trial. At a sentencing hearing on the same day, by seven votes to five, the jury voted for a sentence of life imprisonment without parole. Eighteen months later, on 4 May 1994, the judge overrode the jury and imposed the death penalty. In 1997, the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals ruled that the judge had improperly excluded mitigating evidence at the original sentencing hearing. On remand, with no further jury input, the judge again sentenced David Roberts to death, thereby again overriding the jury’s 1992 vote for a sentence of life imprisonment without parole.

In a dissent in another Alabama case in 2013, two US Supreme Court Justices noted that 95 death sentences had been passed in Alabama on judicial override since 1976, at a rate 10 times higher than overrides in the other direction. Alabama had become a "clear outlier" on life-to-death overrides, and the Justices concluded that "the only answer that is supported by empirical evidence" as to why this was the case, was that "Alabama judges, who are elected in partisan proceedings, appear to have succumbed to electoral pressures". Alabama got rid of its override system in 2017, the last state in the USA to end the practice, but the legislation only applies to new cases. This left Alabama on the wrong side of the retroactive leniency principle, which according to the UN Human Rights Committee, "finds partial expression" in article 15(1) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ratified by the USA in 1992) requiring States parties "to grant offenders the benefit of lighter penalties adopted after the commission of the offence". Three of the jurors from the 1992 trial have supported clemency.

On death row, David Roberts has been diagnosed by prison doctors as having paranoid schizophrenia, with symptoms including psychosis, delusions and hallucinations. According to a psychologist who has reviewed the prison medical record, the severity of David Roberts’ disorder and "how all-encompassing from the record it appears to be" called into serious question his competency for execution under US law, namely whether he has a rational understanding of the reason for and reality of his punishment. A state court judge has ordered a temporary stay of execution pending a psychiatric evaluation after David Roberts’ current lawyers filed a motion that he is not competent. The state has asked for an "expedited" assessment. It is not yet clear how quickly this evaluation will be conducted and how long the stay will remain in place. The use of the death penalty on those with severe mental disabilities is prohibited under international law and standards.

There have been 1,633 executions in the US since 1976, when the US Supreme Court upheld new capital statutes. Alabama has carried out 81 executions since resuming in 1983. Between 1983 and 2007, it carried out 38 executions, and in the 15 years since 2011, it has already carried out 32. There have been 26 executions in the USA in 2025, three of them in Alabama. Amnesty International opposes the death penalty in all cases unconditionally.